Introduction
The Old Guard, released in 2020 on Netflix, brought a fresh twist to the superhero genre. Directed by Gina Prince-Bythewood and led by Charlize Theron, the film centers on a team of immortal mercenaries who fight for justice across centuries. Based on a graphic novel by Greg Rucka (who also wrote the screenplay).
As the highly anticipated sequel (The Old Guard 2) hit Netflix in 2025, fans on social media had mixed reactions. Let’s dive into what made the original film a standout and why the sequel has left many viewers torn.
Why The Old Guard (2020) Stands Out
1. A Fresh Take on Superhuman Storytelling
Unlike typical superheroes in spandex, the characters in The Old Guard are weary warriors burdened by centuries of violence. Charlize Theron’s portrayal of Andromache (Andy), the group’s leader, shows a powerful yet vulnerable woman questioning the purpose of her immortality.
2. Action With Heart
From brutal sword fights to modern gun battles, the film delivers top-tier action. But it’s the emotional weight, the cost of immortality, and the longing for connection that make it truly compelling.
3. Inclusive Representation
The film was widely praised for its LGBTQ+ representation. The love story between Joe and Nicky, two immortal warriors, was portrayed with depth and respect. Audiences loved the now-iconic quote:
“He’s not my boyfriend. He’s all, and he’s more.”
What People Said About Part 1 (Social Media Reactions)
Twitter/X:
“Charlize Theron with an axe? Say less. 🔥 #TheOldGuard”
Reddit:
“I didn’t expect to cry watching an action movie about immortals. Damn, this one hit me deep.”
Instagram:
Fan art of Joe and Nicky flooded IG with captions like “Immortal soulmates > mortal drama.”
YouTube Reactions:
Reviewers called it a “hidden gem” with one saying: “Netflix finally nailed a franchise-worthy original.”
The Old Guard 2 (2025): Fans Are Torn
When Netflix dropped The Old Guard 2, expectations were sky-high. But not all viewers walked away satisfied.
The Main Criticisms:
Abrupt Ending Many viewers complained the film felt “incomplete,” as if only half the story was told.
Weaker Villains Despite casting Uma Thurman as the antagonist, audiences found her character underwhelming.
Lack of Emotional Payoff Some fans felt the character arcs were shallow compared to the original.
But Not All Was Bad:
Visuals & Action The fight scenes remained slick and stylish.
Cast Chemistry: Theron, KiKi Layne, and the core team still had great on-screen synergy.
Final Thoughts: Watch or Skip?
If you haven’t seen The Old Guard (2020), it’s a must-watch emotional, action-packed, and unique in its storytelling.
As for The Old Guard 2, it’s worth watching if you’re invested in the characters. Just be prepared for an open-ended plot that might not offer the closure you expect.
Join the Conversation
Have you watched The Old Guard? What did you think of the sequel?
Let me know in the comments, or share this post and tag a friend who needs to see this film!
